---

Compared Implementations

1. AWS Gateway API Controller (Amazon Elastic Kubernetes Service)
2. NGINX Gateway Fabric
3. Istio
4. Kong Gateway Operator
5. Traefik Proxy
6. Envoy Gateway

Key Parameters for Comparison

• Conformance Status (GA, Beta, Alpha, Preview)
• Supported Gateway API Features
• Layer 7 (HTTP/HTTPS) Support
• Layer 4 (TCP/UDP) Support
• gRPC Support
• TLS Termination
• Mutual TLS (mTLS)
• Traffic Management
• Authentication & Authorization
• Rate Limiting
• Observability
• Load Balancing
• Extensibility
• AWS/Azure/Google Cloud Integration
• Community & Enterprise Support

---

Feature Comparison Table (Latest as of March 2025)

Feature	AWS Gateway API Controller	NGINX Gateway Fabric	Istio	Kong Gateway Operator	Traefik Proxy	Envoy Gateway
Gateway API Support	(GA)	(GA)	(GA)	(GA)	(GA)	(GA)
Layer 7 (HTTP/HTTPS) Routing
Layer 4 (TCP/UDP) Routing		(Experimental)
gRPC Support		(Experimental)
TLS Termination
Mutual TLS (mTLS)	(AWS App Mesh needed)	(Limited)		(Limited)	(Requires Mesh)
Traffic Management	(Basic)	(Basic)
Authentication & Authorization	(AWS IAM)	(Limited)
Rate Limiting	(AWS WAF)	(Limited)
Observability	(AWS CloudWatch)	(Basic)
Load Balancing	(ALB/NLB)
Extensibility	(AWS-focused)	(Limited)
Cloud Integrations	(AWS)			(AWS, Azure, GCP)	(Multi-cloud)
Community & Enterprise Support	(AWS Support)	(NGINX Plus)		(Enterprise)

---

Detailed Breakdown of Each Controller

AWS Gateway API Controller

Status: GA

Best for: Deep AWS integration (IAM, CloudWatch, ALB, NLB)

Limitations: Requires AWS App Mesh for advanced mTLS, basic traffic management

NGINX Gateway Fabric

Status: GA

Best for: High-performance HTTP/HTTPS proxying, enterprise-grade NGINX

Limitations: Limited Layer 4 and gRPC support, mTLS experimental

Istio

Status: GA

Best for: Service Mesh + API Gateway combo, full traffic control

Limitations: Higher complexity, learning curve

Kong Gateway Operator

Status: GA

Best for: API management, authentication, rate limiting, multi-cloud

Limitations: Some Gateway API features still experimental

Traefik Proxy

Status: GA

Best for: Simplicity, automatic TLS, Kubernetes-native

Limitations: Limited Layer 4 support, requires Traefik Mesh for mTLS

Envoy Gateway

Status: GA

Best for: High-performance networking, native Envoy support

Limitations: Requires additional configuration for complex scenarios

---

Key Takeaways: Which One Should You Choose?

For AWS Workloads → AWS Gateway API Controller

For High-Performance & NGINX Users → NGINX Gateway Fabric

For Service Mesh & API Gateway in One → Istio

For Full API Management & Multi-Cloud → Kong Gateway Operator

For Lightweight & Simplicity → Traefik Proxy

For Advanced L4/L7 Proxying & Performance → Envoy Gateway

---

This comparison is based on the latest March 2025 data from Kubernetes Gateway API v1.2.